Amongst the thousands, millions even, of hip-hop artists who have blessed and/or tortured our ears since the genre's beginning in the '70s, none have ever been quite like Aesop Rock. Ian Bavitz, the man behind the unusual stage name, is one of the most formidable, diverse and generally mind-bending artists across the board of rappers, and producers for that matter, what with his complex vocabulary, cartoonish and bouncy musical style, abrasive vocal delivery that's certain to turn some potential fans away, and most importantly, a way of writing things that do make sense eventually, but often only after hours of deciphering down how each individual word fits into the sentence. It's almost difficult to explain how Aesop Rock writes - often in these incredibly confusing diatribes that, when rapped to you at speed, feel like they may as well have been the warblings of a madman. What is perhaps the most incredible moment of an Aesop Rock album listen is when you sit down at the end, find the lyrics transcribed somewhere, and spend hours, days even, working out what the hell they all mean.
Because I'm sure absolutely everyone does that. Right?
Aesop Rock has, deservedly, breached many people's top ten lists, and while these days he has a fan base to rival some of the biggest in the underground, back in 2000 he was just getting started. Whilst he had two projects under his belt ("Music For Earthworms" and "Appleseed", both of which I'll track down someday, and hopefully review too - it's a pity they're so damn hard to find in physical form), the man wasn't lucky enough to get someone to help distribute his music until his third effort, Float, released as the new millennium struck. Float, sometimes considered his proper debut studio album, was a bit of a behemoth, spanning 20 tracks and 70 minutes total, which seemed rather bold for a fledgling artist in Bavitz' position - even with the help of established underground powerhouses Slug (of Atmosphere, obviously) and Doseone, as well as Vast Aire, one half of (at the time) up and coming underground duo Cannibal Ox.
And when you consider Aes' confusing pen game, teamed with the slower, darker production styles found across this album (courtesy of Aes and his main producer at the time, Blockhead), it's difficult to imagine that Float could be capable of keeping the listener's ears engaged throughout it's runtime. It obviously did something however, as Aesop's career would only expand and become even bigger and better from this point on.
It seems that Float was the last stepping stone before greatness when you consider what came after it, but today I want to look back, and see if Float is due a little more appreciation from the hip-hop heads as it's own body of work. Let's get into it!
1. Float (prod. Aesop Rock)
Over a minimalist self-produced beat, Aes takes a couple minutes to introduce himself to all the new fans that the record label bought him, and it's not half bad, even if the production especially sounds very skeletal compared to most of his instrumentals. But I think that's the point - the beat is supposed to serve as little more than a metronome here, and it's the rhymes that are entirely the focus of the listener's attention. And it's a good thing that the vocals are clear on here, as some of them are very difficult to comprehend. On even this very short song, it's very easy to lose the narrative, and I'm sure new listeners to Aes will be confused almost immediately. "Fire ant with a hunger pain gut be gone / belong to something civil, saint, 'cause this Rembrandt paints on" he spits, prior to the memorable "some present impressive lung, some truly learn what a death chant is". Where some Aes lyrics take much coming back to, some do stick out immediately, something I really noticed going through his catalogue. My conclusion here? Not bad. Yes the track's instrumental doesn't sound fantastic, but Aes' lyrics are truly great, and as a short precursor to the record, it is highly intriguing. We're off to a good start.
2. Commencement At the Obedience Academy (prod. Blockhead)
I mean, where the hell do I start? We're two songs in to Aesop's major label catalogue, and already I'm overwhelmed. The lyrics on here, while occasionally very potent and thought-provoking, are just as frequently confusing as all hell. For every "clocked in in '76 and haven't clocked out ever since", there's a "pupil turned pedagogue, benediction to my dream / beaming a billion bottle rockets off the golden mezzanine". I mean - the fuck? This man is completely insane. But as I said before, it's something I like about Aesop. He forces you to come back to his music, just because you need to know what the song was about, and to gain that knowledge many repeat listens are required. And also, you just want to come back because it sounds good. Blockhead's production on here is eerie and menacing, and while initially it seems a little too off kilter, when those hard drums come in it all starts to make sense. This beat is great. And as for the rapping, it's truly extraordinary - this is a fantastic song.
3. Big Bang (prod. Aesop Rock)
Is Aesop Rock the first rapper to ever use the word "pedagogue" in two songs on the trot? Yes, almost certainly. "Big Bang" is this album's most popular track, and it's for a very good reason, as this song is weirdly incredibly catchy - at least when Aes' rapid fire flows in the chorus come in. This beat is a bit more high energy than most of the drearier (in a good way) instrumentals that litter this project, with it's most notable feature being this recognisable violin sound that is goofy, creepy, and brilliant all at the same time, especially during the aforementioned chorus - and Aesop Rock makes us know that it's his by rapping over it absolutely perfectly, dropping bar after bar with brilliant enunciation. "I don't really believe in God, but God I'm scared to death of God, I swear to God I never meant to spill these beans" is one of my favourite lines on the entire record. In fact, this could be the highlight of the album - the instrumental, lyrics, and unique flows certainly put it in high favour. Fucking sick track.
4. Garbage (prod. Aesop Rock)
Aesop Rock attempts to "strap on the blinders and walk directly into the frenzy" with this one, according to the liner notes at least (the booklet gives a short, esoteric description of each individual song's concept, which is helpful), which perhaps explains why this song isn't nearly as upbeat as the previous track - it does offer an almost apocalyptic sound, only if the apocalypse setting was in a circus. There's something weirdly jovial about this instrumental, but I do like it a lot - the drums are the most normal out of any song so far, which leaves a little more room for Aesop's vocals, and thereby making this surprisingly easy to listen to. Of course, a good drum pattern doesn't always make for a good song, but thankfully, it's Aesop Rock we're dealing with here, who cooks up some sick narratives about the people whom he left behind or fell out with before becoming a rapper on a (small) record label. At least that's what I interpret a lot of this is about - I said it was a little easier to decipher, but it still isn't a cakewalk. And the man inevitably sounds great over this beat too. Brilliant tune, and one of this album's underrated gems.
5. I'll Be OK (feat. Slug) (prod. Blockhead)
Probably the most unusual song on this LP - not for Aesop Rock's performance, which is actually one of my favourites so far... but because of everything else. I mean, what the hell was Slug trying to do on this one? Was he paid to make sure Aes looked as good as possible? Because frankly, the guy sounds like a gimmick of himself on this track, and that's coming from someone who really likes Slug as a rapper. Also, the harmonica in this track is really weird, and frankly the instrumental does not fit the vibe of this album at all. If this was a solo Slug song I'd probably say it was pretty poor, but it's very easy to revisit this, as Aesop Rock murders his verse on here, somehow managing to make the beat sound pretty great too. That part when he says "there's a storm outside my tenement" and the beat breaks down somewhat is simply musical perfection. It really lifts the song to a different level - yes this is far from perfect, but it could also be a whole lot worse.
6. Breakfast With Blockhead (prod. Blockhead)
A musical interlude, which sets the tone for the next portion of the album. That's all.
7. Basic Cable (prod. Blockhead)
Aesop's observations on the negative impacts that television has had on society since its inception, something that he's actually discussed multiple times in his career (the back cover of Labor Days even depicts him sat in front of one). This song stands out as being more obviously thematic than a lot of the other songs on here, but even then Aesop frequently comes with some weirdly worded bars anyway. For me, perhaps the main standout of this one is the incredible dark and creepy instrumental that backs Aes' cautionary verses - those violins teamed with the dusty drums make for something unlike what Aes would experiment with again, and it's a very interesting sound. Overall, one of the best tracks yet.
8. Fascination (prod. Aesop Rock)
Like the last track, this one also largely stands out in the Aes catalogue because of the production, but more so because it sounds like a No Limit Records throwaway, with a slight abstract twist to cater to Aes' style of rapping. It's very odd, with the cheap sounding drums and tuneless bass hits making me wonder if Mystikal is about to come in with a guest performance, but it does admittedly kind of work - the sound has a different vibe to it that's a nice break from the darker, occasionally orchestral sounds found on songs either side of this one. Thematically, this track is all about how much Aesop enjoys his own music, which is just something that no-one's ever discussed in their raps before... but because it's Aesop rapping here, he does do it in a way which makes it seem at least somewhat humble (even if he does start the second verse with the line "and everything I touch magnificent"). You probably wouldn't catch the current Aesop making a song like this, but as it stands, I really don't think this one is too bad at all. In fact, it's quite good.
9. Oxygen (prod. Blockhead)
Seriously, seriously great. Blockhead provides Aesop with another violin-tinged instrumental, but even with some other beats that had this element earlier on in the tracklist, it's quite obvious that this one stands out as the best. The violins, along with the echoed vocal samples, come together to make for one of the strongest instrumentals on the entire LP, and one of the best in Aesop's entire career, dare I say it. This one is worth coming back to just for that beat alone. However, there are other elements that I definitely enjoy about this one, all to do with Aes' performance. As well as a hilarious back-and-forth bridge in the middle, this one contains one of the longest verses on the whole album, and it's completely hypnotic how Aes rides the instrumental - you almost forget that he's saying words at all, as it's just too easy to get lost in the flows here. Remember, on Float the man is just starting his career, but on this track it's as if he's had decades to hone his immeasurable skill. This might be the best cut on the whole record.
10. Skip Town (prod. Omega)
Omega One's only contribution to the cause today comes in the form of an instrumental that feels a hell of a lot more light hearted than anything else we've heard so far, save for perhaps the oddly goofy music on "I'll Be OK". That doesn't mean the track suffers though, as while it does kind of break apart the moody, dreary vibe the last three tracks were going for, it's still a fun banger that probably could have done fairly well as a single too, especially given the rather catchy chorus on here. Not only that, but this song also features my favourite lines across the whole album: "I interviewed the sun, he said the future's looking bright / I interviewed the rain, he claimed the sun's truly an asshole!" Classic.
11. 6B Panorama (prod. Aesop Rock)
I'll be honest, this is the first miss on the album for me. And I don't mean to offend anyone when I say this, but occasionally, when he leaves behind the abstract poetry and raps in a more straightforward manner, Aes can come across as kind of corny - and here, in this one verse wonder that lasts a mere two minutes, it feels like Aesop is forcing a concept that has no true message behind it other than "wow look at all the things happening in the city". And it's weird that this doesn't work, because there were many straightforward raps on Integrated Tech Solutions, and I really liked all of them. Here however, it just feels uninteresting, and the instrumental ain't anything to write home about either. Still, at least it's short.
12. Lunch With Blockhead (prod. Blockhead)
Another musical interlude, which sets the tone for the next portion of the album. That's all.
13. Spare a Match (prod. Blockhead)
After a couple more light hearted instrumentals, we're back to something darker here, even if the violins don't seem to be making a return. This Blockhead instrumental is pretty haunting nonetheless, and Aes uses it to discuss the difficulties he faces in finding the few people who can actually help him in life, especially being as weird as he so says he is - and remember, the guy had a major breakdown not too long after this album, so obviously that help was something he needed. The track also features a rather harrowing chorus, where the phrase "to live and die as a brick, brick, brick in the wall" is repeated, showing how while Aes might be the "most distorted orchid in the patch", he's still doing better than most of society, whom fit in their place as an unremarkable brick in a dull and lifeless wall. It's one of the darker tracks on the record overall, but the way it's written, and the way it sounds, make for something very compelling too. What a track.
14. Attention Span (feat. Vast Aire) (prod. Blockhead)
It's interesting how on this album it's always the guest that goes first, before Aesop drops his verse. Perhaps he wasn't as convinced that everything he touched was magnificent as he claimed. Even if Aes is clearly the better rapper on this track, I do find it refreshing when Vast Aire comes through with a verse - and not just because he actually raps normally, unlike whatever the hell Slug was trying to do on "I'll Be OK". No, Vast Aire's verse is dope without being overly abstract at all, making it a lot easier to understand his message here (the message being "I'm a better rapper than you, also your wife sucked me off"). Yes, the contrast between Aesop's thematic and poetic verses with bars like "your girl was on my dick like she was teething" is strange, but I think it kind of works - and predictably Aes kills it anyway (also proving how he can rap well over any instrumental - this horn heavy concoction differs entirely from most of the other shit we've heard so far on Float). This isn't a personal favourite or anything, but it is highly entertaining nonetheless.
15. How To Be a Carpenter (prod. Aesop Rock)
"Documenting those who demand the product before considering the process" is how the CD booklet describes this song, which is a pretty interesting concept... would potentially be more intriguing if I understood what the fuck Aesop was saying in half of this song, but whatever. After the past few self produced instrumentals had some issues, I'm pleasantly surprised at this one having another incredible, slightly dramatic but also eerie as fuck beat that seems to indicate this as one of the most important tracks on the whole album - and while this song has less quotables than most of the others, I still find those interludes where Aes gives his carpenter apprentice a strong talking to, to be hilarious as fuck.
16. Prosperity (prod. Aesop Rock)
Over an instrumental that sounds like a new and improved version of the one we heard on "Fascination", Aesop discusses longevity by "honourable means", and it's at this point in the album where we really start to feel its length. Realistically, this album had no hope of being a true classic, when it is so long and has so many songs that, while good on their own, do have quite a similar sound. This instrumental, with its deep bass and jazzy background horns, feels like it blends in with a lot of what's around it, and while it is great it doesn't exactly stand out. On its own, however, I will commend this song - the rapping is pretty top tier, and when the bassline switches up during the second verse it starts to sound especially good. Overall a good song, but this album is beginning to get a bit long in the tooth.
17. No Splash (prod. Blockhead)
Man, I really do love Blockhead, but goddammit this beat sucks. The main melody is incredibly annoying, and the drums just feel abrasive next to it. This isn't even Aes' best performance - he actually sounds kind of subdued for a lot of it. I'd like to think it's just that this album has gone on for too long at this point and I'm nitpicking, but nah - this might just be Aesop's worst song ever.
18. Drawbridge (feat. DoseOne) (prod. Blockhead)
Really, really weird. I am aware that DoseOne was a member of highly regarded group cLOUDDEAD, but this is the first time I had ever heard him on a song, and... the fuck? Why does his voice sound like that of a bird from a 1960s Disney film? I mean, Aesop Rock has a unique voice, but compared to this guy he may as well be Gunna. While DoseOne does his best to try and fuck up this dope ass Blockhead instrumental, Aes makes sure things go over smoothly, with a fantastic performance on this track that makes you forget about the last song entirely. This song is nothing to blast from the rooftops, but it's certainly not bad either.
19. Dinner With Blockhead (prod. Blockhead)
A final musical interlude, which reminds the listener of the tones set throughout this album. That is all.
20. The Mayor and The Crook (prod. Aesop Rock)
Aesop ends the album fittingly, with this commentary on how people in society tend to fuck each other over, and maybe if the criminals and those in power slay each other, we can build a new society that is far more productive than it is now. Well, at least that's what I got from it. From tracks 16 through 18 I tend to lose a bit of hope in this record, but if there's one thing I can be sure of it's that this track will turn those negative feelings around, as it is truly fucking great. Aesop is a phenomenal rapper as always, and here he cooks up a fantastic chorus and brilliant instrumental to go alongside it - the latter probably being one of the best on this whole record for me. "The Mayor and The Crook" would be topped by Aes countless times on later, superior releases - but on Float, it definitely stands as one of the best and most well thought out tracks on the entire LP. Although that sudden cut out at the end is a little irksome.
While Float has little poor moments across it's hefty 20 track runtime, it still stands out as one of the weakest efforts in Aesop Rock's catalogue, without doubt - and that's including the longer projects he's been dropping recently, as it seems he's learned how to better sustain interest over such a period. Yes, in terms of minutes Labor Days is barely shorter than Float, but at the same time it offers much more variety in sound and song structure - while Float oftentimes feels like many different takes on the same song, with different lyrics and instruments, but very similar flows and moods within the music. Take "Garbage" and "Spare a Match" - both sound great, but at the same time it must be said the two tracks do sound very similar to each other, even in their dystopian lyrical content. And furthermore, Float actually does contain some missteps, something I (spoiler alert) barely ever see in later Aesop projects. "6B Panorama" feels forced, while "No Splash" has one of the most mind-numbing beats I've ever listened to on a hip-hop album (well, maybe that's exaggeration, but it's still pretty bad).
However - and that's a big however - Float is still incredibly impressive, and oftentimes really bloody great. Not only is Aesop's poetic writing hugely intriguing, and of a very high standard, especially considering his age and relative inexperience at the time, but also there are more than a few genuinely fantastic songs across this tracklist - whether we're discussing the eerie and haunting sounds of "Basic Cable" and "Oxygen", the fantastic violin loops on "Big Bang", or the lyrical genius across... well over half of the tracklist if we're being honest. And even if the sequencing on this album, that leaves it sprawling and occasionally samey, was one of it's weaker points, at least Aes had the good sense to end things on a fantastic note with "The Mayor and the Crook", as well as gift us with some pleasant instrumental interludes in there too. While Float shows Aesop at a point where he still needs to work out some things musically, I'd highly recommend a listen to those who haven't - if perhaps not as your introduction to Aesop. There's plenty of great music on here, and for a lesser artist, it could have been a magnum opus. Unfortunately for Float, Aesop would only continue to ascend from here, leaving it an oft forgotten debut. Thanks for reading!
Best Tracks: Commencement at the Obedience Academy, Big Bang, Garbage, Basic Cable, Oxygen, Spare a Match, The Mayor and the Crook
Worst Tracks: No Splash
There will be more Aesop Rock reviews to come - hopefully quite soon if I get my act together!